The Reluctant Heartthrob: How Robert Redford Redefined Stardom

Robert Redford, who has died at 89, was the quintessential movie star, but he was also one of its most famous skeptics. His career was a fascinating paradox: a man blessed with an abundance of natural charisma who actively worked to be seen as more than just a handsome face. His enduring legacy is not just in the iconic roles he played, but in the intelligent way he navigated the machinery of fame.
His roles in two of the most celebrated romances in film history defined his public image. In The Way We Were, his portrayal of Hubbell Gardiner was a study in restraint. Opposite the vibrant Barbra Streisand, his cool, almost detached demeanor created an intense romantic friction that became legendary. He made audiences feel the depth of his character’s emotions without overt displays, a testament to his subtle craft.
This powerful presence was equally effective in the epic romance Out of Africa. As the free-spirited big-game hunter Denys Finch Hatton, his charisma felt as vast and untamed as the African landscape. His chemistry with Meryl Streep anchored the film, demonstrating that his appeal was universal and could elevate a story to Oscar-winning heights. These roles cemented his status as a global symbol of romance.
Yet, the man behind the image was a serious artist uncomfortable with the “heartthrob” label. He sought roles that would challenge his golden-boy persona and poured his creative energy into directing. His greatest off-screen achievement was arguably the founding of the Sundance Institute, a haven for independent filmmakers that has reshaped the landscape of American cinema.
Robert Redford’s life and work serve as a testament to a different kind of stardom. He proved that a movie star could be both an object of public fascination and a serious, dedicated artist. He leveraged his fame to create opportunities for others and left behind a body of work that is celebrated not just for its glamour, but for its intelligence, integrity, and profound impact on film.